Spadezer, The Final Resolve - NGADM 2022 Final Round
1]Technicality 2]Production 3]Composition 4]Emotion 5]BonusPoints
10,9,9,10,10 x2 = [96/100]
I bet you want praise for getting this far? I bet you want to be called a good boy? You want head pats? WELL TOO BAD SPADE. HEAD PATS ARE RESERVED ONLY FOR PEOPLE THAT GET A PERFECT SCORE. YOU MISSED POINTS IN COMPOSITION AND PRODUCTION BECAUSE A LOT LIKE ME, YOU SPEND WAY TOO MUCH TIME IN CAPS LOCK. Give your high action maximum velocity dubstep drums a rest and use a different snare like... once. The track was practically begging for a high action jazz snare or some pitchy koan sound snare to counter the energy. The track went extra hard, which wasn't a bad thing but if your idea of switching up the drums revolves around lowing the volume on them then I might recommend expanding on your drum programming a little. Toss on some pitch bends, add a filter and screw with freq/resonance knobs, toss in a vibraslap, some guiro, switch up the hi-hat rhythms, add some tambs... do literally anything else because the drums were probably the most boring aspect of the track. I hope you don't take too much offense; the track was splendid as usual but it's such a noticeable failing here that I almost took off an extra point. I didn't but I almost did >:C
I think the length of the track had me forgiving some aspects, you really went hard into this contest. I might have mentioned earlier that the score sheets had you sitting at number one seed? Congrats for leading the contest as well as you did. Others might say the judges had a dubstep bias, maybe we did? Honestly, I would have loved to of heard some experimental grindcore or maybe some accordion math rock... but this was definitely a year for EDM artists to go extra hard and your style capitalized. Shout out to the orchestral artists that made it this far as well but EDM artists have that small advantage of finding all the tones in the spectrum and making use of them advantageously. Perhaps too often though, EDM tracks can get very boring when it's just a brick of constant action so I'm glad you get yourself outside the box. Honestly, I'm a little surprised you didn't slip in one screaming woodland creature towards the end for old times' sake. I'd have chortled over it quietly.
Edit: I went back to your track a few times while listening to Uxvellda's track and I think a small oversight might exist in how you started the track with a mighty (but corny) phased synth patch. I like to get to the action quickly when I write so I know the itch to come out of the gate strong, but you might have benefit from using a little less at the beginning? I think it's fair to point to Uxvellda's track, he opened with some strong orchestral drums before hitting me with those big boring repetitive dubstep patterns. Despite not having the diversity in the dubstep drums that I asked of you, he managed to counter-balance them with some very atmospheric orchestral sounds. You both had incredible sounds coming into the end, but I felt Uxvellda was slightly stronger :C
Regardless of my issues (of which I have many issues totally unrelated to your music) I wish you the best Spade, and good luck with the other judges! Excelsior!